| Bowl Game | Mike's Pick | Tim's Pick | Actual Winner |
| New Mexico Bowl | Colorado State | ||
| Las Vegas Bowl | USC | USC | |
| Idaho Potato Bowl | San Diego State | San Diego State | San Diego State |
| New Orleans Bowl | Louisiana-Lafayette | ||
| Beef 'O' Brady's Bowl | East Carolina | East Carolina | East Carolina |
| Hawaii Bowl | Oregon State | Oregon State | |
| Little Caesar's Bowl | Pittsburgh | Pittsburgh | |
| Poinsettia Bowl | Utah State | ||
| Military Bowl | Marshall | ||
| Texas Bowl | Syracuse | Syracuse | |
| Fight Hunger Bowl | Washington | Washington | |
| Pinstripe Bowl | Notre Dame | Notre Dame | Notre Dame |
| Belk Bowl | North Carolina | ||
| Russell Athletic Bowl | Louisville | Louisville | Louisville |
| Buffalo Wild Wings Bowl | Kansas State | ||
| Armed Forces Bowl | Navy | Navy | Navy |
| Music City Bowl | Ole Miss | Ole Miss | Ole Miss |
| Alamo Bowl | Oregon | Oregon | Oregon |
| Holiday Bowl | Texas Tech | ||
| Advocare V100 Bowl | Arizona | Arizona | |
| Sun Bowl | UCLA | UCLA | UCLA |
| Liberty Bowl | Mississippi State | Mississippi State | Mississippi State |
| Chick-fil-A Bowl | Texas A&M | Texas A&M | |
| Gator Bowl | Nebraska | ||
| Heart of Dallas Bowl | North Texas | North Texas | |
| Capital One Bowl | South Carolina | South Carolina | South Carolina |
| Outback Bowl | LSU | LSU | LSU |
| Rose Bowl* | Michigan State | ||
| Fiesta Bowl* | Central Florida | Central Florida | |
| Sugar Bowl* | Oklahoma | ||
| Cotton Bowl | Missouri | Missouri | |
| Orange Bowl* | Clemson | ||
| BBVA Compass Bowl | Vanderbilt | Vanderbilt | Vanderbilt |
| GoDaddy Bowl | Arkansas State | ||
| BCS Championship* | Florida State | Florida State |
Picks breakdown
| Common Picks | 12 | 24 |
| Mike's Solo Picks | 8 | 11 |
| Tim's Solo Picks | 3 | 11 |
| Mike's Total Picks | 20 | 35 |
| Tim's Total Picks | 15 | 35 |
Batsu game goes to: Tim. His fate was officially sealed by Central Florida's victory over Baylor in the Fiesta Bowl.
