Thursday, March 10, 2016

Episode 189 - MLB Parity vs. NFL Parity

Football is headed to where baseball was - and baseball is headed to where football was.

Today's topic: parity in the NFL vs. parity in MLB

This topic came up as a by-product of the NFL Los Angeles debacle.

Mike's observation: more championship parity in the World Series than in the Super Bowl.

Here's the distribution of Super Bowl championships all-time:
  • Pittsburgh Steelers - 6
  • Dallas Cowboys - 5
  • San Francisco 49'ers - 5
  • Green Bay Packers - 4
  • New England Patriots - 4
  • New York Giants - 4
  • Denver Broncos - 3
  • LA/Oakland Raiders - 3
  • Washington - 3
  • 3 teams - 2 each
  • 7 teams - 1 each
9 teams (28% of the NFL) have won 37 out of 50 (74%) Super Bowls.  The other 13 (26%) have been won by just 10 teams (31% of the league).  13 teams (41%) have yet to win the Super Bowl.

Here's the distribution of World Series championships since 1966 (the season that ended with Super Bowl I).  Please note that there was no World Series in 1994 because of the players' strike:
  • New York Yankees - 7
  • Oakland Athletics - 4
  • St. Louis Cardinals - 4
  • Baltimore Orioles - 3
  • Boston Red Sox - 3
  • Cincinnati Reds - 3
  • San Francisco Giants - 3
  • 9 teams - 2 each
  • 4 teams - 1 each
7 teams (23% of MLB) have won 27 out of 49 (55%) World Series in the Super Bowl era.  The remaining 22 (45%) have been won by 13 teams (43% of MLB).  10 teams (33%) have yet to win the World Series in the Super Bowl era.  Only 2 of those 10 - Chicago Cubs (1908) and Cleveland (1948) - have won the World Series prior to the Super Bowl era.

Tim makes the argument that in the immediate aftermath of the 1994 players' strike, MLB had significant disparity as the Yankees were able to buy all the big-name talent while lower-revenue teams - like the Royals and the priced-out-of-existence-so-they-moved-to-DC Montreal Expos - struggled at the gate and on the field.  We're starting to see the attitudes of then-Yankees owner George Steinbrenner manifest themselves in the NFL in the form of Jerry F. Jones.



Click here to download.